The Best Gears logo

Best Canoes

Editorial Team
Last modified at August 7, 2026
The Esquif Mallard is the highest-rated all-around canoe in this guide, while the Old Town Discovery 133 favors stability and capacity and the B 16 favors speed. Choose among them by matching hull behavior, weight, capacity, seating, and material to the water and load you expect. The guide also includes a lightweight solo option, motor-ready square-stern designs, and an inflatable canoe for paddlers who value portability.

Why You Can Trust Us

  • Rankings based on aggregated user data, not personal bias
  • Payment never guarantees inclusion
  • Updated regularly as new reviews emerge

We may earn from affiliate links at no extra cost to you.

Esquif Mallard Canoe

The Esquif Mallard is a rugged, all-around canoe built for stability and adaptability. Its wide, shallow-arch hull keeps it steady in calm waters, making it a great choice for beginners or families. The T-Formex construction absorbs bumps and scrapes, so it holds up well to rocky shorelines and frequent use. With a weight capacity that accommodates gear for multi-day trips, it’s as practical for fishing as it is for casual lake outings. The symmetrical design allows for easy solo paddling from the center seat, while the roomy interior fits two adults comfortably. It’s not the lightest option, but the trade-off is a canoe that feels solid and dependable on the water.
Esquif Mallard Canoe
Stability
4.2 / 5
Performance
4.3 / 5
Comfort
4.1 / 5
Versatility
4.8 / 5
Weight & Capacity
4.6 / 5
Durability
4.7 / 5
Dimensions

12 ft 4 in × 3 ft 3.75 in × 1 ft 1 in

Weight

59 lb

Capacity

500 lb

Material

T-Formex

Seat Count

N/A

Warranty

1 Year

GOODS

  • Exceptionally stable for flatwater and mild rivers
  • Highly versatile for solo or tandem paddling
  • Durable T-Formex material resists impacts

BADS

  • Heavier than some composite canoes

Compare this product with...

Esquif Mallard CanoevsOld Town Discovery 133

Old Town Discovery 133

The Old Town Discovery 133 is a rugged, three-layer polyethylene canoe built for all-day comfort and reliability. Its wide beam and shallow arch hull deliver a steady ride, even with a full load of gear or an extra passenger. The contoured seats and adjustable backrests reduce fatigue on long paddles, while the multiple carry handles make it easier to manage despite its weight. The canoe’s durable construction stands up to scrapes and knocks, and its generous capacity accommodates camping gear, coolers, or even a dog. It tracks well in calm waters but can feel sluggish in wind or current. Ideal for lake trips, slow rivers, or casual fishing outings.
Old Town Discovery 133
Stability
4.1 / 5
Performance
4.4 / 5
Comfort
4.2 / 5
Versatility
4.7 / 5
Weight & Capacity
4.4 / 5
Durability
4.2 / 5
Dimensions

13.25 × 3.375 × 1.167 ft

Weight

78 lb

Capacity

800 lb

Material

Three Layer Polyethylene

Seat Count

3

Warranty

Limited lifetime hull

GOODS

  • Exceptionally stable for flatwater and mild rivers
  • High weight capacity for gear-heavy trips
  • Versatile design handles solo or tandem paddling

BADS

  • Heavy for solo portaging

Compare this product with...

Old Town Discovery 133vsOld Town Discovery 119

Old Town Discovery 119

The Old Town Discovery 119 is a solo canoe designed for easy handling and portability. Its 11-foot-9-inch frame offers ample space for gear, making it ideal for fishing, crabbing, or a quiet lake getaway. The lightweight build simplifies transport, whether you're loading it onto a car or carrying it to the water. While it excels in versatility and capacity, its stability can feel less confident in rougher conditions. Durability varies, with some users reporting minor scuffs over time. Overall, it’s a practical choice for calm waters and relaxed outings.
Old Town Discovery 119
Stability
3.2 / 5
Performance
4.4 / 5
Comfort
4.2 / 5
Versatility
4.8 / 5
Weight & Capacity
4.7 / 5
Durability
3.8 / 5
Dimensions

11.75 × 2.71 × 1.13 ft

Weight

50 lb

Capacity

500 lb

Material

Three Layer Polyethylene

Seat Count

1

Warranty

Limited Lifetime Hull Warranty

GOODS

  • Lightweight for easy transport
  • Spacious for gear and solo trips

BADS

  • Mixed durability with potential scratches
  • Moderate stability in choppy water

Compare this product with...

Old Town Discovery 119vsSea Eagle TC16

Sea Eagle TC16

The TC16 feels like a steady platform you can trust on lakes, slow rivers, and even light white‑water. Its wide beam and thoughtfully placed seats keep paddlers comfortable for hours, making it a solid choice for family outings or fishing trips. The hull is built from a tough composite that stands up to bumps and sun exposure without warping. Because it prioritizes stability, the canoe isn’t the quickest on the water, so you won’t win any sprint races. The added weight also means you need a vehicle with a decent roof rack or a trailer to transport it. Overall, it excels when you value confidence and comfort over speed and ultra‑light portability.
TC16
Stability
4.7 / 5
Performance
3.3 / 5
Comfort
4.7 / 5
Versatility
4.6 / 5
Weight & Capacity
3.4 / 5
Durability
4.4 / 5
Dimensions

16 × 3 ft 2 in × 1 ft 8 in

Weight

55 lb

Capacity

915 lb

Material

1000 Denier Reinforced PVC

Seat Count

2

Warranty

3-year limited warranty

GOODS

  • Rock‑solid stability makes it feel safe in choppy water
  • Spacious, comfortable seating for longer trips
  • Durable construction that resists dents and UV damage

BADS

  • Slower acceleration and lower top speed than sport‑oriented canoes
  • Heavier hull limits how many people or gear you can carry comfortably

Compare this product with...

Sea Eagle TC16vsOld Town Discovery 158

Old Town Discovery 158

The Old Town Discovery 158 is a roomy, stable canoe built for relaxed paddling and multi-day trips. Its wide beam and flat bottom keep it steady in lakes, slow rivers, and protected coastal waters, making it a great choice for beginners or families. The three-seat design offers flexibility for solo, tandem, or even a third passenger, and the molded seats with backrests add comfort for longer outings. Durability is solid for a polyethylene canoe, though it won’t hold up to rough treatment like a Kevlar or fiberglass model. The tradeoff for its stability and space is weight—this isn’t the easiest canoe to car-top alone. It handles well in calm conditions but isn’t designed for whitewater or speed.
Old Town Discovery 158
Stability
4.4 / 5
Performance
4.2 / 5
Comfort
4.2 / 5
Versatility
4.7 / 5
Weight & Capacity
3.6 / 5
Durability
3.6 / 5
Dimensions

15.67 × 2.96 × 1.13 ft

Weight

87 lb

Capacity

1150 lb

Material

Three Layer Polyethylene

Seat Count

2

Warranty

Limited lifetime hull warranty

GOODS

  • Exceptionally stable for calm and moderate waters
  • Highly versatile for fishing, touring, or casual paddling
  • Spacious and comfortable seating for long trips

BADS

  • Heavy for solo transport
  • Polyethylene hull scratches more easily than composite materials

Compare this product with...

Old Town Discovery 158vsNorthstar B 16

Northstar B 16

The B 16 is a versatile tandem canoe built for efficiency and stability. Its sleek design glides smoothly, making it ideal for longer paddles or multi-day trips. The hull’s durability stands up to rocky shorelines and rough water, while the roomy interior accommodates gear for two. It tracks straight with each stroke, reducing fatigue on long hauls. The trade-off is a bit of extra weight, which can make portaging a workout. Still, it’s a reliable choice for paddlers who prioritize performance over featherlight carry.
B 16
Stability
3.9 / 5
Performance
4.7 / 5
Comfort
3.9 / 5
Versatility
4.2 / 5
Weight & Capacity
3.9 / 5
Durability
4.1 / 5
Dimensions

16 × 2.96 ft

Weight

SL: 38 lb
BL: 40 lb
IXP: 61 lb

Capacity

Optimal Load: 300–600 lb
Displacement @ 2” WL: 190 lb
Displacement @ 3” WL: 340 lb
Displacement @ 4” WL: 460 lb
Displacement @ 5” WL: 620 lb

Material

BlackLite: Carbon, Innegra, Aramid
StarLite: Aramid
IXP: Innegra, Aramid

Seat Count

2

Warranty

Usable life of the canoe

GOODS

  • Slices through water with minimal effort
  • Handles choppy conditions well
  • Durable hull resists scrapes and impacts

BADS

  • Heavier than some solo canoes
  • Wider beam slows it slightly in calm water

Compare this product with...

Northstar B 16vsSun Dolphin Scout SS Square Stern Canoe

Sun Dolphin Scout SS Square Stern Canoe

The Scout SS Square Stern Canoe is a well-rounded choice for paddlers who want a stable, comfortable ride. Its square stern design makes it easy to add a small motor if you need extra power, while the roomy interior accommodates gear or a second paddler. The canoe performs well on calm waters and mild currents, making it a solid option for recreational outings. It’s built for versatility, whether you're fishing, exploring, or just cruising. However, it’s not the lightest canoe out there, and the materials may not hold up as well in more demanding environments. A great pick for those who prioritize adaptability and comfort over extreme durability or weight savings.
Scout SS Square Stern Canoe
Stability
4.1 / 5
Performance
3.9 / 5
Comfort
4.2 / 5
Versatility
4.4 / 5
Weight & Capacity
3.9 / 5
Durability
3.4 / 5
Dimensions

14 × 3.2 × 1.3 ft

Weight

84 lb

Capacity

765 lb

Material

Rugged UV-stabilized Fortiflex® High Density Polyethylene

Seat Count

3

Warranty

Limited Lifetime Warranty

GOODS

  • Stable and comfortable for solo or tandem paddling
  • Versatile design handles calm lakes and mild rivers
  • Spacious square stern allows for motor mounting

BADS

  • Durability could be better for rough conditions
  • Heavier than some specialized models

Compare this product with...

Sun Dolphin Scout SS Square Stern CanoevsEsquif Prospecteur 16

Esquif Prospecteur 16

The Prospecteur 16 is a classic tandem canoe built for adventure, offering a great balance of speed and carrying capacity. Its symmetrical hull design makes it easy to paddle solo from the center seat or with a partner, and the shallow arch bottom provides decent tracking without sacrificing maneuverability. The durable three-layer polyethylene construction holds up well against scrapes and impacts, while the open design allows for flexible seating and gear arrangements. At 16 feet, it’s long enough to handle larger loads but still manageable for most paddlers to transport. The slightly rockered ends help with turning, though this does mean it requires a bit more effort to keep straight in windy conditions.
Prospecteur 16
Stability
3.6 / 5
Performance
3.9 / 5
Comfort
3.8 / 5
Versatility
4.4 / 5
Weight & Capacity
4.4 / 5
Durability
3.8 / 5
Dimensions

16 × 2.9 ft

Weight

65 lb

Capacity

1000 lb

Material

T-Formex

Seat Count

N/A

Warranty

3-year limited warranty

GOODS

  • Highly versatile for flatwater and mild rapids
  • Excellent weight capacity for gear-heavy trips
  • Lightweight for its size

BADS

  • Moderate stability in choppy conditions

Compare this product with...

Esquif Prospecteur 16vsOld Town Discovery Sport 15

Old Town Discovery Sport 15

The Old Town Discovery Sport 15 is a rugged, do-it-all canoe built for stability and adaptability. Its three-layer polyethylene hull resists scrapes and dings, making it a reliable choice for rocky shorelines or frequent use. The 15-foot length and wide beam provide a steady ride, even with a full load of gear or multiple paddlers. It handles well in calm lakes, slow rivers, and mild coastal waters, though it’s not designed for whitewater. The open deck layout offers plenty of space for fishing setups or camping gear, and the built-in rod holders add convenience. The main tradeoff is the basic seating, which can get uncomfortable on longer outings.
Old Town Discovery Sport 15
Stability
3.7 / 5
Performance
3.9 / 5
Comfort
2.9 / 5
Versatility
4.4 / 5
Weight & Capacity
3.9 / 5
Durability
3.9 / 5
Dimensions

15 ft 3 in × 3 ft 4 in

Weight

114 lb

Capacity

Paddled: 1,650 lb
Motorized: 800 lb

Material

Three Layer Polyethylene

Seat Count

3

Warranty

Limited Lifetime Hull Warranty

GOODS

  • Highly versatile for fishing, touring, and casual paddling
  • Durable three-layer polyethylene construction
  • Excellent weight capacity for gear and passengers

BADS

  • Seats lack padding for long trips

Compare this product with...

Old Town Discovery Sport 15vsPelican Explorer 14.6 DLX canoe

Pelican Explorer 14.6 DLX canoe

The Pelican Explorer 14.6 DLX is a rugged, no-frills canoe built for stability and durability. Its wide beam and flat bottom keep it steady, making it a great choice for beginners or anglers who need a reliable platform. The three-layer polyethene hull shrugs off scrapes and bumps, so it holds up well in rocky or shallow waters. At 14'6", it offers plenty of space for gear or a second paddler, though the weight makes it a two-person job to carry. The seats are basic and can get uncomfortable after a few hours, so plan on adding cushions for longer outings. It’s not the fastest or lightest, but it’s a dependable workhorse for relaxed paddling and multi-use trips.
Pelican Explorer 14.6 DLX canoe
Stability
4.1 / 5
Performance
3.6 / 5
Comfort
3 / 5
Versatility
4.1 / 5
Weight & Capacity
2.4 / 5
Durability
3.9 / 5
Dimensions

14.9 × 3.2 × 1.6 ft

Weight

90 lb

Capacity

800 lb

Material

Polyethylene

Seat Count

2

Warranty

2-year limited warranty

GOODS

  • Highly stable on calm and moderate waters
  • Durable polyethene hull resists impacts
  • Versatile for fishing, touring, and casual paddling

BADS

  • Heavy and cumbersome to transport
  • Seats lack padding for long trips

Compare this product with...

Pelican Explorer 14.6 DLX canoevsEsquif Mallard Canoe

Trust & Transparency

  • Data-driven rankings from real user reviews
  • Affiliate partnerships don't influence our methodology

We may earn commission from links.

Conclusion & Final Verdict:

For most paddlers, the Esquif Mallard is the strongest all-around choice in this lineup, with the highest overall rating and strong scores for durability, versatility, stability, and performance. The Old Town Discovery 133 is the better fit when stability and an 800 lb capacity matter more than a lighter carry. The Old Town Discovery 119 is the most portable solo option at 50 lb, while the B 16 is the performance-oriented pick for paddlers who prioritize efficient travel. If motor mounting matters, consider the Scout SS Square Stern Canoe or Old Town Discovery Sport 15. Match the final choice to your water conditions, expected load, and transport setup.

See All Guides

Most Useful Comparisons

Compare the closest-rated products and other matchups that have helped readers make a decision.

Last Modified August 9, 2026

Northstar B 16vsSun Dolphin Scout SS Square Stern Canoe

The Northstar B 16 excels in performance and durability, while the Sun Dolphin Scout SS Square Stern offers superior stability, comfort, and higher load capacity.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Old Town Discovery 119vsOld Town Discovery 133

The Discovery 119 is a lightweight solo canoe that's easy to transport, while the Discovery 133 offers greater stability, higher load capacity, and three seats for tandem use. Choose the 119 for solo, portable trips; pick the 133 if you need stability and extra passenger space.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Old Town Discovery 133vsEsquif Mallard Canoe

The Esquif Mallard is lighter and built with ultra‑durable T‑Formex, while the Old Town Discovery 133 offers a massive 800‑lb capacity and three seats. Pick the Mallard for easy portaging and rugged use, or the Discovery for heavy‑load family trips.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Old Town Discovery 158vsNorthstar B 16

The Old Town Discovery 158 delivers rock‑solid stability and versatile fishing setups, while the Northstar B 16 is lighter, faster and built with high‑tech composites—pick the Discovery for family or multi‑task paddling, the B 16 for performance‑focused trips.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Old Town Discovery Sport 15vsEsquif Prospecteur 16

The Old Town Discovery Sport 15 offers a massive 1,650 lb load capacity and motor‑ready design but weighs 114 lb, while the Esquif Prospecteur 16 is a lightweight 65 lb canoe with far more comfortable seating.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Old Town Discovery Sport 15vsPelican Explorer 14.6 DLX canoe

The Old Town Discovery Sport 15 packs more capacity and motor versatility, while the Pelican Explorer 14.6 DLX is lighter and a tad more stable – choose based on load needs versus transport ease.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Sea Eagle TC16vsOld Town Discovery 119

The Sea Eagle TC16 delivers rock‑solid stability and a massive 915 lb capacity, while the Old Town Discovery 119 is lighter, faster and more versatile for solo outings. Choose the TC16 for family or heavy‑load trips; pick the Discovery 119 for speed, portability and single‑person use.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Sea Eagle TC16vsOld Town Discovery 158

The Sea Eagle TC16 is lighter, more stable and comfortable for easy transport and family outings, while the Old Town Discovery 158 is heavier but offers higher load capacity, better speed and a lifetime hull warranty—pick the TC16 for stability and portability, the Discovery for power and payload.

Read Comparison
Last Modified August 9, 2026

Sun Dolphin Scout SS Square Stern CanoevsEsquif Prospecteur 16

The Sun Dolphin Scout SS offers rock‑solid stability, a comfortable three‑seat layout and a square stern for a motor but is heavier, while the Esquif Prospecteur 16 is lighter, carries more gear and is built tougher for adventure.

Read Comparison

How We Rated These Products

Stability

Covers how steady the canoe feels, its tracking ability, responsiveness to steering, and overall safety on water.

Performance

Encompasses speed, power output, and how efficiently the canoe moves through water.

Comfort

Looks at seating ergonomics, adjustability, and overall rider comfort during paddling.

Versatility

Assesses how well the canoe adapts to different uses, its portability, storage options, and customizability.

Weight & Capacity

Evaluates the canoe’s dry weight versus the maximum load it can safely carry.

Durability

Measures build quality, material resilience, and resistance to water damage.