Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt vs REI Co-op REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt

Comfort is crucial for a backpacking quilt as it directly impacts the quality of your sleep, which in turn affects your overall backpacking experience. A comfortable quilt allows you to sleep well, toss and turn without getting tangled, and regulate temperature easily. The Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt excels in providing a comfortable sleep with its soft material and thoughtful design, allowing users to sleep in various positions without feeling restricted. It offers a perfect rectangle shape that can be wrapped around you like a blanket, providing ultimate comfort and protection. On the other hand, the REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt offers more mobility inside the quilt with a generous foot box and girth, reducing the feeling of confinement and allowing for a more relaxed sleep. Both quilts have their unique comfort features, making it a tie in this category as they cater to slightly different preferences.

Warmth is a critical factor for backpacking quilts, especially in colder conditions. A warmer quilt ensures that you stay cozy and well-rested, even in chilly environments. The Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt is praised for keeping users warm and providing excellent heat retention with its 850 fill power Hungarian goose down and water-resistant finish. It also features a draft collar and pad attachment system that enhances its warmth. Similarly, the REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt is highly regarded for its 30-degree rating and water-resistant down, which stabilizes the down and keeps it in place, providing a warmer sleeping experience. Both quilts offer outstanding warmth, making it a tie in this category as they both excel in keeping users warm in various conditions.

Durability is essential for a backpacking quilt as it needs to withstand the rigors of outdoor use. A more durable quilt will last longer and provide better value for money. The Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt is made with 20 denier nylon, which is very durable, more resilient, and less prone to tearing. It also features high-quality stitching and a water-resistant finish, adding to its durability. In comparison, the REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt uses a 15 denier shell and lining, which, while durable, is slightly less robust than the Hammock Gear's 20 denier fabric. This makes the Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt the winner in terms of durability, as it offers a more robust construction that can better withstand rough use.

Ease of use is important for a backpacking quilt as it affects how quickly and easily you can set up your sleep system after a long day of hiking. The Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt is designed with a sew-in foot box option, extra buckle, and an adjustable cinch cord, making it easy to get in and out of the quilt. It also features a ground attachment system and buckles for the pad strap that are adjustable and flush, enhancing its ease of use. The REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt, while also easy to use, has a cord system and toggle system that allows for adjustments to the girth of the quilt. However, the Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt's design is slightly more user-friendly, making it the winner in this category.

Versatility is key for a backpacking quilt as it allows you to use the quilt in various conditions and settings. A versatile quilt can be used as a blanket, wrapped around you like a cocoon, or adjusted for different temperatures. The Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt is highly versatile, suitable for both hammock and ground campers, and can be used in various seasons. It features tie outs for pad connection and a neck drawstring for head coverage, making it adaptable to different temperatures and sleeping preferences. The REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt is also versatile, with adjustable toggles for more legroom or warmth and a hybrid baffle design that prevents down shift. Both quilts offer excellent versatility, making it a tie in this category as they cater to a wide range of uses and preferences.

Packability is crucial for backpacking quilts as it affects how easily you can carry and store the quilt in your backpack. A more packable quilt takes up less space and is easier to carry, leaving more room for other essentials. The Hammock Gear Burrow Top Quilt is lightweight and packable, weighing 740 grams and fitting easily into a stuff sack. It can be compressed down even smaller with a compression sack, making it highly packable. The REI Magma Trail 30 Quilt is also highly packable, with a 19-ounce quilt that compacts into a small stuff sack and is easy to pack and carry. Both quilts excel in packability, making it a tie in this category as they both offer excellent compressibility and lightweight design.