REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts vs Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts

Pocket accessibility is crucial for hikers who need to carry essentials like keys, phones, and snacks. Both the REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts and the Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts score equally in this category, offering multiple pockets for easy access. The REI shorts feature lots of pockets, including front and back side pockets, making it convenient to store and retrieve items. The Patagonia shorts, on the other hand, come with four stretchy side pockets and a zippy back pocket, providing ample storage space. However, some users noted limitations in phone storage and key jingling with the Patagonia shorts. Overall, both shorts offer excellent pocket accessibility, making it a tie in this category.

Breathability is essential for staying cool and comfortable during long hikes. The Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts excel in this category with a higher breathability rating. Users have praised the Patagonia shorts for being super breathable and cool to run in, thanks to their breathable fabric. The REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts also offer decent breathability, suitable for comfortable hiking in warm weather. However, the Patagonia shorts' superior breathability makes them a better choice for those who prioritize staying cool during intense physical activity.

Fit and comfort are paramount for any hiking gear, as they directly impact your mobility and overall experience. The Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts score higher in this category, offering a perfect fit for mobility with an elastic waistband and supersoft lining. Users have consistently praised the Patagonia shorts for their comfort and flexibility, making them ideal for all-day wear. The REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts also provide a comfortable fit with an elastic waist and lots of room to move, but they fall slightly short compared to the Patagonia shorts. For those seeking the utmost comfort and flexibility, the Patagonia shorts are the clear winner.

Durability is a critical factor for hiking shorts, as they need to withstand rugged terrains and frequent use. The Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts outshine the REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts in this category. Users have noted that the Patagonia shorts are very durable and maintain their quality even after multiple washes. The REI shorts, while durable, have received mixed reviews regarding their ability to handle rugged conditions. For hikers who need shorts that can endure tough environments, the Patagonia shorts are the better choice.

Water handling is important for hikers who may encounter wet conditions or need to cool off in water. The REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts perform better in this category, with users noting that they handle getting wet well. The Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts have a DWR water repellent finish, but users have reported that it doesn't make a significant difference. For those who anticipate encountering water or needing quick-drying fabric, the REI shorts are the preferable option.

Security features, such as secure pockets, are essential for keeping valuables safe during hikes. The REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts offer better security with a drawstring waist and cinch-up features. The Patagonia Outdoor Everyday Shorts have a discreet zipper pocket, but some users have noted issues with key jingling and suggested a key strap. For hikers who prioritize secure storage for their valuables, the REI shorts are the better choice.