REI Co-op Trailmade Hiking Shorts vs REI Co-op Sahara Cargo Shorts - Men's

Easy access to gear is crucial on the trail, where you may need to grab a map, snack, or tool without stopping. A higher pocket accessibility rating means more pockets, deeper compartments, and secure closures that stay open when you need them. The Sahara Cargo Shorts score 4.1/5, praised for abundant storage, zippered thigh pockets, and practical deep pockets, while the Trailmade shorts earn 3.9/5 with a solid but smaller set of front and back pockets. For hikers who rely on multiple items, the Sahara Cargo Shorts provide a clearer advantage.

Breathable fabrics keep you cool and dry, especially on hot days or steep climbs. Better breathability translates to faster moisture wicking and less overheating. The Sahara Cargo Shorts lead with a 4.4/5 rating, thanks to a lightweight nylon blend that lets air flow freely and dries quickly. The Trailmade shorts sit at 3.6/5, offering decent airflow but fewer mentions of moisture‑wicking performance. If staying cool is a priority, the Sahara Cargo Shorts win.

A comfortable fit reduces chafing and allows full range of motion, essential for long days on uneven terrain. Higher scores indicate elastic waistbands, stretch fabrics, and designs that stay in place. The Sahara Cargo Shorts earn a strong 4.7/5, highlighted for a four‑way stretch nylon‑spandex blend, relaxed fit, and adjustable waist. The Trailmade shorts receive 4.1/5, noted for an elastic drawstring waist and roomy cut but lacking the same level of stretch. Overall, the Sahara Cargo Shorts deliver a more refined, adaptable fit.

Durability determines how well shorts survive scrapes, branches, and repeated use. A higher durability rating signals abrasion‑resistant fabrics and reinforced areas. The Sahara Cargo Shorts dominate with a 4.7/5 rating, praised for tough nylon, reinforced knees, and resistance to tearing on rugged trails. The Trailmade shorts score 3.2/5, with mixed feedback that they are “really durable” but also show occasional snagging. For demanding terrain, the Sahara Cargo Shorts are the clear choice.

Water handling matters when you encounter rain, streams, or splashes; better resistance keeps you drier and the fabric from soaking. The Sahara Cargo Shorts achieve a 3.9/5 rating, benefitting from a durable water‑repellent (DWR) coating and overall water‑resistant construction. The Trailmade shorts sit at 3.6/5, noted as merely “average” in wet conditions. While neither is a dedicated rain short, the Sahara Cargo Shorts handle moisture slightly better.

Secure pockets keep valuables like keys and wallets from falling out during vigorous movement. Higher security scores reflect zippered or reinforced pockets that stay closed. The Sahara Cargo Shorts lead with a 4.1/5 rating, highlighted for zippered cargo pockets that lock items in place. The Trailmade shorts earn 3.6/5, relying mainly on a drawstring waist for a modest level of security. For peace of mind on the trail, the Sahara Cargo Shorts are superior.