Smith Vantage 2 MIPS vs OutdoorMaster ELK MIPS
Why You Can Trust Us
- Side-by-side analysis based on real user feedback
- Unbiased comparisons, not influenced by partnerships
- Updated as new data becomes available
We may earn from affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
| Vantage 2 MIPS | ELK MIPS | |
|---|---|---|
![]() | ![]() VS | |
| Certifications | ASTM F2040, CE EN 1077 | ASTM F2040, CE EN 1077 Class B |
| Rotational Impact System | MIPS | MIPS |
| Construction | Three-piece hybrid shell with full Koroyd coverage | In-mold PC shell with EPS liner |
| Weight | 18 oz (size M) | 16.9 oz (listed) |
| Ventilation | 40 vents, adjustable (dual top/side regulators) | 8 vents |
| Fit Adjustment System | BOA 360 Fit System dial | Rear size-adjustment dial |
| Warranty | 3 Years | 2 Years |
| Size Range | S–XL (51–67 cm) | S–L (51–61 cm) |
| Goggle Integration | AirEvac goggle venting | Rear goggle strap retainer |
| Audio Compatibility | Aleck audio compatible | Not specified |
| Removable Ear Pads | Not specified | Yes |
| Buckle Type | Fidlock magnetic buckle | Not specified |
| Smith Vantage 2 MIPS | OutdoorMaster ELK MIPS |
|---|---|
![]() | ![]() |
| Certifications | |
ASTM F2040, CE EN 1077 | ASTM F2040, CE EN 1077 Class B |
| Rotational Impact System | |
MIPS | MIPS |
| Construction | |
Three-piece hybrid shell with full Koroyd coverage | In-mold PC shell with EPS liner |
| Weight | |
18 oz (size M) | 16.9 oz (listed) |
| Ventilation | |
40 vents, adjustable (dual top/side regulators) | 8 vents |
| Fit Adjustment System | |
BOA 360 Fit System dial | Rear size-adjustment dial |
| Warranty | |
3 Years | 2 Years |
| Size Range | |
S–XL (51–67 cm) | S–L (51–61 cm) |
| Goggle Integration | |
AirEvac goggle venting | Rear goggle strap retainer |
| Audio Compatibility | |
Aleck audio compatible | Not specified |
| Removable Ear Pads | |
Not specified | Yes |
| Buckle Type | |
Fidlock magnetic buckle | Not specified |
Protection
Vantage 2 MIPS
ELK MIPS
Protection is the most important category for any ski helmet, because it determines how well the shell and liner handle impacts and rotational forces. Buyers of the Vantage 2 MIPS point to full-coverage energy absorption, MIPS designed to reduce rotational forces, and the added Koroyd layer as the core of its safety story, earning it a 4.1 out of 5 rating. The ELK MIPS earns a higher 4.7 out of 5 with a much larger body of feedback, where buyers consistently highlight the MIPS liner and overall sense of safety, and one customer describes wearing it through a real crash. For a buyer, this means both helmets offer MIPS, but the ELK MIPS has the stronger track record in what owners say about safety. The Vantage 2 still brings extra protective layering through Koroyd, so it is not a weaker design on paper. Overall, product2 wins this category, although the ELK's advantage is based on more reported experience than on a dramatically different technical approach.
Comfort
Vantage 2 MIPS
ELK MIPS
Comfort matters because a helmet you cannot wear for a full day is one you will stop using, and fit and padding shape how it feels on long runs. The Vantage 2 MIPS is described as seamless and lightweight, with reviewers saying it stays comfortable through long days without sacrificing head coverage, which supports a 3.9 out of 5 score. The ELK MIPS scores 4.3 out of 5 with a large volume of feedback praising its soft liner, plush ear padding, and adjustable ear covers that keep ears warm, and many buyers call it comfortable all day across a range of temperatures. Some ELK reviewers did report fit or comfort complaints, so the feedback is not universally positive. For most buyers the ELK MIPS offers the more proven comfort profile, while the Vantage 2 is a good fit for those who prioritize a light, low-profile feel. Product2 wins this category, but trying either helmet on before buying is worth the time.
Durability
Vantage 2 MIPS
ELK MIPS
Durability affects how many seasons you can count on a helmet, and it is especially relevant when comparing a premium model against a budget one. The Vantage 2 MIPS has no meaningful durability feedback in the available evidence, so its 3.0 out of 5 score reflects a lack of detail rather than a known weakness. The ELK MIPS scores slightly higher at 3.4 out of 5, but that score rests on very limited feedback, with one buyer reporting it held up through a full season in varied conditions. Neither helmet has a strong long-term record, so neither should be treated as a proven multi-season pick based on owner reports alone. Warranty coverage is a useful tiebreaker, and the Vantage 2 offers three years compared with two years on the ELK. For buyers who want a multi-season helmet, product2 edges ahead on the thin feedback available, but checking warranty terms before buying is the practical step.
Ventilation
Vantage 2 MIPS
ELK MIPS
Ventilation matters because heat and sweat build up quickly during active runs, and a helmet that traps moisture can become uncomfortable or even affect goggle performance. The Vantage 2 MIPS stands out here with a 4.4 out of 5 rating, driven by dual vent regulators that let you control airflow, a high count of around 40 vents, and separate top and side vent sets that buyers say help prevent sweatiness and manage temperature. The ELK MIPS scores 3.9 out of 5, with eight vents, side vents that release warm air, and removable ear pads that help on warmer days, while also blocking cold wind. Its breathable mesh and simpler design suit skiers who want steady warmth in cold conditions with reasonable cooling on the go. For buyers who run hot or ski aggressively, the Vantage 2 offers clearly more adjustable airflow, while the ELK is adequate for moderate conditions. Product1 wins this category clearly.
Fog Prevention
Vantage 2 MIPS
ELK MIPS
Fog prevention matters because goggles that fog up can ruin visibility at the moment you most need it, especially in cold, humid conditions. The Vantage 2 MIPS scores 3.7 out of 5, with buyers reporting that its AirEvac system and helmet-goggle fit help pull air through goggles to reduce fogging, though they note results depend on goggle pairing and conditions. The ELK MIPS scores 3.3 out of 5, with front vents credited for keeping goggles clear, but feedback on this is very limited. Both helmets are in the middle range here, and neither should be assumed to solve fogging on its own. The Vantage 2 has more specific supporting feedback and a dedicated goggle venting design, which makes it the better bet for goggle-focused buyers. Product1 wins this category, but testing with your own goggles remains important.
Ease Of Use
Vantage 2 MIPS
ELK MIPS
Ease of use matters because you adjust and remove your helmet many times a day, often with gloves or mittens on. The Vantage 2 MIPS scores 4.1 out of 5, with its BOA 360 dial, Fidlock magnetic buckle, and one-hand removal strap praised for quick, glove-friendly adjustment. The ELK MIPS scores 3.9 out of 5, with buyers appreciating its adjustable back buckle and rear dial, which can be tightened on the fly even with a camera mounted. Both systems are easy to use, but the Vantage 2 offers a more refined one-handed experience that works especially well with mittens. The ELK's rear dial is simple and effective for getting a snug fit, so it remains a practical choice for most skiers. Product1 wins this category, although the difference is modest.
Trust & Transparency
- Data-driven rankings from real user reviews
- Affiliate partnerships don't influence our methodology
We may earn commission from links.
Conclusion & Final Verdict:
Choose the Vantage 2 MIPS if you run hot, ski or ride hard, wear mittens often, or want the best airflow, goggle venting, wider size range, and longer warranty. Choose the ELK MIPS if you want a budget-friendly helmet with a comfortable, well-regarded liner, removable ear pads, and strong protection feedback. For most buyers focused on comfort and value, the ELK is the safer everyday pick, while the Vantage 2 is the better choice for active, warm-running skiers who want premium ventilation and quick adjustment. Try either helmet on with your goggles before buying to confirm fit.
Related Comparisons
Smith Vantage 2 MIPSvsGiro Ledge MIPS
Choose the Smith Vantage 2 MIPS if airflow control and quick, glove-friendly adjustment matter most. Choose the Giro Ledge MIPS if you want a lighter, more comfortable helmet that works well under goggles and full face masks.
Smith Vantage 2 MIPSvsGiro Tor Spherical
The Smith Vantage 2 MIPS leads on ventilation, warranty, and weight, while the Giro Tor Spherical is stronger for protection, comfort, and one-handed ease of use. Choose the Vantage 2 if you run hot on active days, or the Tor Spherical if you want the most protective and comfortable all-round fit.
Smith Vantage 2 MIPSvsOakley MOD1 PRO
Smith Vantage 2 MIPS pulls ahead on airflow, fog-friendly venting, and quick glove-friendly adjustment, while Oakley MOD1 PRO wins on a snug, adjustable fit and a tougher Dura-Matter shell. Choose the Vantage if you run hot and want a light helmet, and the MOD1 PRO if you want a durable hard shell with a precise fit.
Smith Vantage 2 MIPSvsOakley MOD5
The Smith Vantage 2 MIPS is the better pick for buyers who run hot and want the most airflow, fog control and lightweight comfort, while the Oakley MOD5 suits those who prioritize a quick glove-friendly buckle and goggle-compatible strap system, though its fit can run tight.
Smith Vantage 2 MIPSvsPOC Fornix MIPS
The Smith Vantage 2 MIPS is the better choice for skiers who run hot and want standout ventilation, one-hand glove-friendly adjustment, and a 3-year warranty. The POC Fornix MIPS suits comfort-focused riders who want a light, cushioned fit and removable ear pads, but its shell and liner need regular inspection.
Smith Vantage 2 MIPSvsPOC Obex MIPS
The Smith Vantage 2 MIPS leads on ventilation, goggle fog control and quick glove-friendly adjustment, so it suits riders who run hot or ski hard. The POC Obex MIPS is the softer, more comfortable option for buyers who want plush padding and a light feel, though its durability and airflow trail the Smith.

