Xero Shoes Z-Trail EV Sandal vs Tread Labs Redway Sandal

Comfort is critical in hiking sandals because you’ll be wearing them for hours over uneven terrain, and poor cushioning can lead to fatigue or soreness. The Z-Trail EV delivers a plush, barefoot feel with thick foam that many find pleasant for casual walks and light trails, but its cushioning lacks the structured support needed for extended hikes. The Redway, by contrast, is consistently described as ridiculously comfortable with a footbed that keeps feet happy even on long treks, thanks to its supportive yet lightweight midsole. While both are comfortable, the Redway’s combination of cushioning and arch support makes it the clear winner for serious hikers who need all-day relief.

Durability determines how long your sandals will last under regular use, especially when exposed to rocks, mud, and frequent wear. The Z-Trail EV has notable concerns, with users reporting straps breaking and soles separating over time, undermining its 5,000-mile warranty promise. In contrast, the Redway is built with welded, reinforced materials and a sturdy construction that users describe as tough and long-lasting, with no reports of premature failure. For anyone planning to use their sandals frequently or on rugged terrain, the Redway’s proven resilience makes it the far more reliable choice.

Traction on varied terrain prevents slips and boosts confidence on rocky, muddy, or loose surfaces. The Z-Trail EV offers decent grip with its Navi traction pattern and performs well on dry trails, but its shallow treads struggle on wet or slippery conditions. The Redway improves on this with a more aggressive tread design that hooks up reliably across diverse surfaces, including rocks and loose dirt, giving users greater stability. While neither is a boot, the Redway’s superior outsole design makes it the better option for technical or unpredictable trails.

A secure, customizable fit prevents blisters and keeps your foot locked in during movement. The Z-Trail EV uses adjustable straps and a wide toe box, which helps many users achieve a good fit, though some report the sandals don’t stay secure or have sizing inconsistencies. The Redway offers a more refined fit system with multiple size options and a custom-feel design that adapts to different foot shapes, ensuring no bagginess or slippage. For hikers with wider feet or those who need a truly locked-in feel, the Redway’s fit is more consistently reliable and less prone to adjustment issues.

Support, especially arch support, is essential for preventing foot fatigue and injury on long hikes. The Z-Trail EV is designed as a true barefoot sandal with no structured arch support, which suits minimalist enthusiasts but leaves many hikers feeling unstable or sore after extended use. The Redway, however, features an APMA-certified arch support system that matches the medium height of Tread Labs’ proven insoles, providing real biomechanical stability. For anyone with flat feet, high arches, or who hikes more than a few miles, the Redway’s support isn’t just a bonus—it’s a necessity.

Breathability keeps feet cool and dry, reducing the risk of blisters and discomfort in hot weather. Both sandals excel here with airy designs that dry quickly: the Z-Trail EV’s open webbing lets air flow freely, while the Redway’s recycled polyester uppers are also breathable and cool. Neither is a standout in extreme heat, but both perform adequately, with no clear advantage in moisture management or drying speed. For most users, breathability won’t be the deciding factor between these two.